Image
Image
Remote Services for Natural Gas Liquids production
Eyebrow
Success stories

Bently Nevada Remote Services saves ~600 Tons NGL production

4 min read


The background

The customer has a Bently Nevada Supporting Services Agreement (SSA) in place to support both Machinery Diagnostic Services (MDS) and System Health and Maintenance. In March 2021, they urgently requested that Bently Nevada supported a case of critically high vibration on a LP Gas Compressor unit, which increases the sour pressure gas from 0.5 bar to 15 bar.

Since the operations don’t have a standby unit available, the non-availability of this machine would result in 40% of NGL production loss from the total plant production capacity of 1500 Tons/day. The machine train was comprised on two centrifugal compressors driven by an asynchronous motor through a speed-increasing gearbox.

Machine Train Diagram
 
The challenges

On March 18, 2021, the customer observed high vibration on the HP compressor Non Drive End (NDE) bearing. The vibration excursion reoccurred on the following day, which resulted in the tripping of the unit. The vibration signature and machinery behavior haven’t been observed since initial commissioning of the machine train.

The vibration level at the compressor NDE bearing reached as high as 445 µm pp at the critical speed during coast down, considering that the alarm level is 60 µm pp and trip level happens at 75 µm pp. Given the high criticality of this machine and the urgency of restoring the unit to avoid production losses, the customer requested Bently Nevada’s remote support.

Bently Nevada extended immediate remote support by reviewing the System 1 archive data provided by the customer. The data showed clear signs of rub, suspected to be at the HP NDE seal and bearing. The machinery datasheet provided by the customer indicated a liquid film seal type. Bently Nevada requested the customer to verify the type of compressor seals, and it was confirmed that the compressor were upgraded few years back and fitted with dry gas seals (DGS).

The presence of extremely high vibration amplitudes on compressor NDE bearing at critical speed and the high slow roll was due to a change in rotor dynamics caused by severe rub leading to a thermal bow. Bently Nevada recommended the customer to inspect the compressor HP NDE DGS and bearing for signs of rub.

The solution

Upon inspection of the compressor per Bently Nevada recommendations, the customer found 2-3 mm of scoring on the rotor at the DGS throttle ring and rubbing marks on the NDE bearing pads.

Root cause analysis performed by the customer revealed foreign material ingress (piping scales) from liquid carryover. This occurred twice in the last two months, causing rubbing at the DGS throttle ring which further resulted in secondary rubbing at the bearing. The seal-gas supply alarm was in bypass  due to instrumentation malfunction, which could have helped in early detection of the problem.

The significance

Bently Nevada’s prompt support at midnight on the weekend helped the customer to accurately pinpoint the correct inspection location, avoiding costly unplanned downtime. The immediate corrective actions  of the inspection and seal/bearing replacement made it possible for the customer to restore the machine train back to normal operation in minimum time. When the unit was restarted, vibration levels were found to be well within acceptable limits for normal operation.

We suspect that without Bently Nevada’s support, the customer would have done additional startup trials that could result in additional failures to other parts and taken at least couple more days before deciding to open the machine for inspection. We estimate that a minimum of three days of NGL production (600 Tons) would be lost.

The experience of Bently Nevada MDS engineers for analyzing such machines from various customers led to a quick analysis and conclusions. Bently Nevada strives to demonstrate customer value through long-term customer partnerships, delivering unmatched machinery diagnostic capability and 24/7 remote support, driving timely outcomes that make a difference.

Polar plots for vibration excursions at compressor NDE bearing exhibit loops generated by continuous changes at the synchronous vibration response (1X) and phase angle reveals symptoms of rub.
Fig.2 Polar plots for vibration excursions at compressor NDE bearing exhibit loops generated by continuous changes at the synchronous vibration response (1X) and phase angle reveals symptoms of rub.

 

Trend, Polar & Orbit plots for vibration excursion at the compressor NDE bearing.
Fig.3 Trend, Polar & Orbit plots for vibration excursion at the compressor NDE bearing. The polar plots exhibit loops generated by continuous changes at the synchronous vibration response (1X) and phase angle and compensated orbit plots of low and high vibration were almost circular with forward procession. 

 

The trend plots of HP case compressor showed very high overall vibration amplitudes during coast down after trip mainly at 1X frequency component whereas no prominent change was observed on LP case compressor.
Fig.4 The trend plots of HP case compressor showed very high overall vibration amplitudes during coast after trip mainly at 1X frequency component whereas no prominent change was observed on LP case compressor.

 

Change in rotor dynamics because of rub compared to normal coast down
Fig.5 The bode plots of HP case during coast down on 19th March 2021 (Direct, 1X) showed a change in rotor dynamics because of rub compared to normal coast down on 28th Feb 2021 (Direct, 1X). The 1X filtered orbit time-base plots of slow roll speed also indicated the symptoms of rub.   

 

 Inspection Results
Fig.6 Inspection Results